What to do when they won’t pay

Debt Collection guide for small businesses

Are your clients late in paying you each month & hold back making payment for as long as possible? Or Do they not even bother to pay you at all? Recent research has proven that this can create serious cash-flow problems for small business owners. This blog will give you some advice and also hints and tips to hopefully overcome this issue.

Let the Judge Decide?

Do you rush straight to court or not?

judge-fines-himself

It’s been reported that more and more British businesses are moving towards legal proceedings against their late paying clients, sooner rather than later. Whilst court action is an effective way of recovering unpaid debts, it can be expensive if the debtor does not pay and a solicitor will usually not carry out any back ground checks on the company or the individual if you are dealing with a sole trader to let you know if they have any sizeable assets, have been taken to court in the past, if there are any outstanding charges registered against the company and if they are in the process of going into liquidation or signing a formal agreement to deal with their debts like a CVA, IVA, Administration, Trust Deed or Bankruptcy. All of these are important factors to consider before taking the plunge and raising a court action, we think this should be used as a last resort, rather than the first port of call, as it will also break all relationships you had with that client.

We do think a bold approach is key to a small businesses survival, Late Payments are having deeper consequences than many people realise. Recent research found that 6% of small businesses had to make at least one employee redundant last year as a direct consequence of late payment, and one in 20 were also forced to reduce staff working hours and shifts due to their clients failure to pay on time.

Dangle the Carrot?

Business-people-shaking-hands

If your client is late in paying you we would always recommend that you ask for payment in full, however this is sometimes not always possible if your client simply does not have the funds. Instead you could offer them a repayment plan where you would get your money back by instalments, some money is always better than none. Always get a copy of the repayment schedule agreed in writing, email or letter is fine, this way if it’s defaulted on it can be used as evidence to prove the debt is not disputed and also that your client has defaulted on the agreement and is failing in their ability to repay their debts as they all due. You can also notify them in writing that their debt has reached an unsustainable level and you will no longer be able to provide goods and services unless they agree to the repayment plan. If your clients have some money, they will probably pay you using this method, you will have avoided damaging your relationship with them, and they will think you are doing them a favour so hopefully it will be smiles all-round!

Turn up the heat?

graph

When you think your efforts have failed and you are starting to doubt that you will ever see your money again, it’s time for a more assertive approach. Many businesses large or small will enlist the services of a Debt Collection Agency like ourselves. A word of warning, there are many rouges in our industry, you should go with a well-established, reputable firm who are members of Regulatory bodies like The Credit Services Association & The Institute of Credit Management. They should also not take any upfront fees from you and work on a No Collection – No Fee basis.

The debt collection agency will serve demands and apply pressure on your client’s using debt recovery methods such as, telephone calls, emails, face to face visits. This is often enough for your client to pay up and as they are working on a no collection no fee basis then you are not going to be left with a legal bill to pay if they do not recover anything for you.

It’s really important that the debt collection agency understands the relationship you have had with your client as if we can establish this in our first demand letter that is served then it can increase our chances of making a recovery without the need for any further action. In some cases a custom built letter crafted to that particular client, not a standard template can give your client the nudge that was needed and can preserve the relationship with that client.

Bring the action?

If all of this has not worked then it’s time to consider issuing legal proceedings against your client, before accepting your application the court will expect you to have made a reasonable effort to come to an agreement with your client. You can use a solicitor or some debt collection agencies such as Debt Collect UK can issue your legal proceedings on your behalf. The Government’s Money Claim Online Service www.moneyclaim.gov.uk  makes the process easy and can eliminate the need to use a solicitor so the cost can be limited to just the court fee, if you are in England or Wales. The legal process in Scotland and Northern Ireland is slightly different and we would recommend you visit www.scotcourts.gov.uk  for Scottish actions or www.courtsni.gov.uk for actions in Northern Ireland if you wish to raise them yourself.

Raising Legal Proceedings can be complex and in most instances we would recommend that you use the services of a solicitor who is experienced in Debt Collection, or an experienced reputable Debt Collection Agency who can pass this to a solicitor on your behalf so that your case is watertight with no errors before being submitted to court.

Defendants in England & Wales are required to state if they have any reasons for non-payment within 14 days of the claim or they will face a County Court Judgement. Again the process in Northern Ireland & Scotland is slightly different and the timescales to respond depend on the amount of the debt owed. You will have to go to a court hearing or if you have a solicitor they maybe able to go on your behalf if the debtor denies or disputes owing you the money. Please be warned, defended actions can be very expensive, so if you have an inkling the action is going to be defended you should consider the size of the debt and if it is going to be worth your while pursuing, as once you start the legal process it can be difficult to stop it. If they admit owing the money, or don’t respond you can get the court to order them to pay. If they still don’t pay you will need to have the court action enforced. You can use Bailiffs or High Court Enforcement Officers in England, Wales or Northern Ireland or Sheriff Officers in you are in Scotland.

Hurt in the pocket

p17-cash

It takes time and money to chase outstanding debts, and many businesses end up writing off small debts below £500.00 as they are simply not worth pursuing. They may look to learn from their mistakes and tighten up their credit control procedures to prevent this happening again. You should always consider the size of the debt and your chances of recovery, before instructing any action.

No one wants to suffer in silence

man-tape-mouth

The stress of tight cash flow on small business owners is horrendous and no one likes the thought of having to undertake debt recovery measures against their clients, but why suffer in silence and put your own business and employee’s livelihoods at risk when you have so many other options that you could use to recover your bad debts?


10 SIMPLE STEPS NOT TO BE HIT BY FRAUD

  1. Always treat newly-formed firms and new accounts with suspicion, beware of a new client trying to place a large order for their first or second order
  2. There are certain styles of business names long firm fraudsters seem to favour. Beware of the words, Euro, International, Worldwide, Wholesale, Trading and Distribution, please air particular caution to these types of businesses
  3. If the trader has been a long-established company, beware of rapid change in Directorship, Company Secretary etc. These indicate the company has changed ownership, and may have been hijacked by fraudsters to obtain credit
  4. Use a recognised credit reference agency to check the company or individual out in detail. If the company has submitted accounts to Companies House, check the dates match and the firm of accountants who submitted the accounts actually exist
  5. Check with the landlord of the premises and neighbouring businesses to confirm the length of occupancy.
  6. Ensure receipt of original paperwork – never accept copies or faxed documents. Do not accept hand-written faxed orders for goods
  7. Ask for Trade References, don’t just call the number supplied and ask them to supply you with information. Goggle map the business to check it actually exists and again ask neighbouring businesses how long they have been there for.
  8. When following up a Trade Reference ask unusual questions like, Have you worked with this Company at any different addresses? Have they changed their names? How well do you know them? (If the person at the end of the phone is hesitant they are usually working from a script, which wont include questions like this)
  9. Check the company has a website, and it looks genuine, there should be no spelling mistakes, and should relate to the business they carry out. If the website looks very basic, carry out more checks
  10. Fraudsters very rarely have company email addresses, they are usually linked to Yahoo, AOL, and Hotmail Accounts, if this is the case your suspicions should be aroused straight away

Sales vs Credit Misconceptions

There is a popular misconception that the Credit Control Department is “anti-sales” and they will try to create barriers towards the sales effort wherever possible. This “Sales v’s Credit” attitude is wrong and can only be removed by strong personal relationships and education of the sales staff that a sale is not a sale unless the company is paid for it.

sales-vs-credit

You can improve the process with a full understanding of each others roles, which are very similar in a lot of ways. Both departments want to –

  1. Develop new business
  2. Ensure continuity of that business
  3. Make a profit
  4. Achieve Success

The education process begins with regular meetings between the two departments. Discussions points should include, collection results, problem accounts, new prospects, unresolved queries, frauds and potential frauds, any information shared from Credit Circles or competitors on poor payers, cases that may go legal or to debt collectors and updates on cases that have already been passed to solicitors or debt collectors, and proposed customer visits.

The Credit Controller or Manager of Credit Control should visit prospective and existing customers as regularly as possible with the sales team. This again will cement the relationship between the two departments and give the Credit Controller a clearer understanding of the sales teams daily challenges.

In the same way each new and existing sales person should be given an induction to the role of the Credit Control Department and their key objectives towards profitability.

Selling – bringing home the business – is a tough job, especially in the current financial climate, and the sales team should be congratulated when any new business is received. The Credit Controller’s part in this process is to seek to do business at every possible opportunity. If a customer is deemed un-creditworthy, you should look for alternative solutions like Cash on Delivery, Personal Guarantees, or Guarantors. If the Credit Control Department decides to offer credit on the basis on the Personal Guarantees or Guarantors they should be thoroughly investigated first to ensure that they are credit worthy and also have assets should anything go wrong with the account so they could be pursued to recover any monies owed. Credit Control should never decline the account, without giving reason to sales.

The most important point to note is communication. Credit Control should always keep the sales department informed of any key changes to their accounts whether it be good or bad. Credit Control should never forget that the account also belongs to sales as well as them. The sales team are extremely valuable to many credit processes including collections, risk assessment and gathering information. The setting of clients terms and credit limits will also become an easier process when a good relationship exists between Credit Control and Sales staff. Monthly, or weekly meetings should be held between sales and credit control and all of the points in paragraph 3 should be discussed, documented, and action points should be noted and actioned before the next meeting. This adds to the commitment, trust and overall communication between the two departments.

If the sales team is treated professionally and with confidence, Credit Control will gain their trust and respect in their options, and future dealings will become easier because you are working together. Sales people and generally positive, driven people, and credit professionals should be equal to this attitude. The stuffy, blue suited, office bound individual is a thing of the past. The Credit Control department is the link between sales and finance and makes a real difference to corporate profits and liquidity. This should not be overlooked at any stage.

The Credit Control department should use positive language when addressing the sales team. They should not talk negatively about “blacklists” or “stopping supply” even though this maybe their only course of action left. Credit Control should use other phrases focusing on positive action and try to be pro active about highlighting potential issues with sales before they arise. Credit Control should praise sales on their successes and focus on how their customer skills and strengths can help Credit Control achieve their objectives.

Without sales, the company would not survive. Without money and cashflow, the company will not survive. Allowing credit accounts to clients is an incentive for sales to win business. This incentive comes at a cost, and the role of the Credit Control department is to keep the cost to a minimum by collecting, communicating, and minimising bad debt, and also creating a fantastic environment for clients that will ensure repeat orders for the sales team.


Best Ways to Approach Collecting Your Ledger – Telephone v Letters

letter-telephone

The telephone can be a very powerful tool and without question is the most effective method of collecting outstanding debts, but you must consider the time element involved in calling everyone in your customer base.

Ask yourself two questions –

  1. How many customers do you have?
  2. What are the values of your debts?

Based on the answer to these questions, you can structure your overall approach to the collections.

If your ledger consists of 10 – 20 high value accounts, ensure you call them all (or even visit them) personally. These are key accounts to your business and should be treated well in order to establish sound relationships with your clients and ensure prompt payment of the accounts.

If you have a good working relationship with a key client, do your homework, by building rapport with them. For example, if they tell you personal information about themselves (birthdays, anniversaries, names of children, or the area they live in) note them on the account and use them in future conversations. It seems simple, but this will highlight to the client that you are generally interested in what they have to say, which builds a better relationship with them, as well as keeping you a step ahead should you ever need to make a collection from them.

If your ledger is made up of 1000 – 2000 low turnover accounts, then it would be impractical and not a good use of your time to call them all personally. A structured letter cycle approach should be adopted. Please see my previous blogs Reminder Letters for Invoices Part 1 & 2 for advice on this.

Most commonly there will be a mixture of phone calls and letters. You should prioritise your workload to find a balance, ensuring your high value, high risk and prestigious clients always receive a personal call, whilst sending letters, faxes or email to your low value, low exposure customers.

Get it Right from the Start

The chances are if an account is not set up or chased properly at the point of opening, then its likely that it will fall into arrears. Make sure the correct checks are carried out when opening the account –

  1. Do you have a credit application form completed?
  2. Have you checked and called the telephone numbers supplied and do they relate to this particular client? (Always ensuring you have more than one number, and a landline as well as a mobile)
  3. Have you checked the references supplied on the credit application form? Don’t just telephone the numbers supplied to check this out, check on Google maps etc that the addresses and companies supplied for the references actually exist. Fraudsters will supply you with fake address and company details for references and the number you call will probably just go straight to them or someone working with them and they will just tell you what you want to hear in the hope that you open the account and send them the goods.
  4. Credit Check the Limited Company or individual and arrange a credit limit and payment terms based on your findings

Remember, how much profit can be lost from overdue accounts or bad debts, so its imperative you get this correct first time.

If there is any ambiguity in your contracts or payment terms, it may severely hinder your future collection efforts. If your quotes, order forms, invoices and statements send the wrong message or information, the confusion may be costly.

Ensure your business is not just selling at any cost, and expecting to pick up the pieces. If you think a particular account is high risk, look at your costs and factor in a higher profit margin where possible, so if the account goes bad then at least you will have recouped some of your losses already.

If you have a high account query rate, and you are experiencing consistent slow payment, there will usually be a reason for this. Its your task to ascertain the root cause of this reason, and resolve it.

A few very important points to remember and follow whilst collecting –

  1. Always be polite and communicate effectively
  2. Be persuasive and persistent and do not be ‘put off’ easily
  3. Do not waste time – don let anybody waste your time – do it now
  4. Use targets and spreadsheets to focus your collection activity

Remember that payment is as important a part of your contract as the goods, services, sales, dispatch and pricing policy. If you provide the best service to your customer, you should expect payment in the same manor.

Set Your Plan of Action

Firstly, ensure you call at the right times of day. 9.30 – 12.00 and 2.00 – 4.00 are generally the best collection windows, avoiding lunch and early departures. Try to arrange your day around these periods.

You should set yourself regular cash goals to target and monitor your collection efforts.

Remember to use the 80/20 principle. This will bring the majority of the cash your business requires. Use days Sales Outstanding (Debtor Days) to set yourself (or your team) cash targets for the month ahead, and adopt rewards and incentives (however small) for your key achievers.

Place emphasis on any ’90 day overdue’ balances (including problematic debts) to ensure they don’t become uncollectible. Memories become very distant as time goes by and its your job to ensure an account is never outstanding for too long.

Recovery agents have collected debts aged 3 years and over just by picking up the phone and communicating. The offending company simply told them ‘nobody has ever asked for it before!’ although I do understand these instances are rare it is sometimes worth chancing your arm to see what happens.

Use your sales ledger system effectively to produce relevant reports necessary to assist your collections (i.e an aged debt report or detailed invoice analysis), and keep credit control history logs for all customers up to date, with detailed notes so you know exactly what was said in your last communication with them. This can then be recalled the next time you speak to them.

Send your paperwork out on time (i.e invoices, statements, and reminder letters) and ensure you are following up any queries or issues with accounts .


Reminder Letters for Invoices - Part 2

The second part of our series looks at the final stages of payment reminders.

3. Example of Deteriorating Payments Letter

To be sent when payments from a previously prompt-paying customer have started to deteriorate.

Dear

Amount overdue:
Invoice No:
Date:
Payment terms:
Credit limit:
Account:

You have in the past settled your account promptly but we notice that, in recent months, payments have been received outside the agreed terms and we wonder if there is any special reason for this.Read more


Reminder Letters for Invoices - Part 1

Many companies are afraid in the current economic climate to chase their clients for money in fear they may lose them to a competitor. Please remember we are all working to make money and a good customer is a paying customer.

If you have issued an invoice and one of your clients has not paid this its your responsibility to call them to find out exactly what is going on. There maybe a genuine reason for them not paying you and it shows you are on the ball and will not be fobbed off with excuses when it comes to getting paid, even you’re biggest and best clients should understand if you chase them for overdue invoices and you should not be afraid to do this.

The first part of our series looks at the early stages of payment reminders.

Read more


10 Excuses for Non Payment & How To Deal With Them

invoice

It’s a fact that you will encounter almost everyday in any form of Credit Control a number of customers who will try an excuse to buy some time and hold on to their cash.

A company has a legal obligation to meet its debts as they fall due. If they cannot they are technically trading whilst insolvent.

  1. The cheque is in the post – The oldest and worse excuse in the book! Ask them to send you a copy of the cheque if possible,  then ask them to confirm the date it was processed or sent, the exact amount and cheque number, what address the cheque was sent to and was it sent First Class. If the debtor is telling the truth they will generally be willing to accept and answer your questions. If they are not, the excuse will probably not be used again because of the professionalism and through nature of your questioning.
  2. We have not received your invoice or statement – This is a very common delaying tactic. Firstly have the debtor confirm the address that you have to send invoices to for that client to check it is correct. Have the debtor confirm to you that this is the only reason for withholding payment, then use a “closed” question like “If I email you a copy of the invoice or statement will this account be paid today?” If the debtor is not prepared to make an agreement once the invoices or statements are received then this is often a sign that the excuse is a simple delaying tactic and more probing questioning is needed.
  3. The debtor is never available – As Debt Collectors this is something we experience on a daily basis. Though it is unusual for a customer never to be there, its often used as an excuse and delay tactic. To counter this, ask to speak to an alternative decision maker within the business. Call at different times of the day, even before 9am and after 5pm, ask for mobile numbers for the debtor or directors of the company or escalate or complaint to higher management. If this doesn’t work fax and post a “Letter Before Action”, to the Director’s of the company giving them 7 days to pay, put a stop on the customers account if necessary until payment is received.
  4. The Accounts Department are only open 9am to 12pm one day a week – if it sounds implausible then it often is, look and think about the size of the company, are they large enough to warrant having an accounts department? Are they a really large organisation that would need a large accounts department, that would be open during normal office hours? Be prepared to challenge the situation and ask yourself of the importance of this person in the payment process. A company Director or partner in the business should be perfectly able to forward payment and tie up loose ends before the Accounts Department finally make an appearance in their office.
  5. The Goods were Damaged not received or arrived late – Your debtor may have a legitimate claim here, but not however if the delivery was over a few weeks ago, question why they have not contacted you to discuss and sort out the problem. Most deliveries can be tracked online so check and verify the information the debtor is supplying you with, whilst you are talking to them.  Ensure you investigate the nature of the debtors claim but request payment for the balance of the account. Act quickly to resolve any disputes so any invoices can be cleared as soon as possible.
  6. I am changing my bank account – Ask for proof of the situation and ask if the debtors new bank can call you to clarify the situation. Changing bank accounts is a very quick and easy process these days even for a business so this should not be holding up payment for a great amount of time a few days at the most. Point out to the debtor that their stance is unacceptable and that the costs of supporting the debtors non payment (I.E Interest Charges & Late Payment Fees) could be passed onto them if full and immediate settlement is not made. Push for payment either electronically or by way of a personal directors cheque.
  7. I’m too busy to pay you – If the debtor states this to you and if they genuinely are busy they then must be making plenty of money to pay your outstanding invoice. Use probing questions to ask how busy they are, when they are going to be paid and when you can expect your cash. Highlight to the debtor that in today’s modern environment everyone has access to online banking and it only takes a matter of seconds to process a payment to you. Press the debtor for immediate payment, if that cannot be accommodated arrange a date within the next day or so and follow this up with the debtor if you are not paid on the agreed date.
  8. I have not been paid by my clients yet – Debtors feel that they are entitled to withhold payment until such time as their clients make payment to them. Clearly this is not the case and a strong line needs to be taken. Ask the name and address of their debtor and the expected date of payment. Your immediate reaction maybe to feel sorry for the debtor, you need to remind them that you are now in a similar position due to their non payment, re confirm your payment terms and ask for payment immediately. As a company they have an obligation to pay on time. If the person you normally speak to with regards payment of accounts doesn’t seem bothered ask to speak to the manager or the director of the company to highlight the issues you have discussed
  9. I have a cashflow problem – The cash shortage is their problem, you have carried out work in good faith and expect to be paid for the work you have completed. Ask the debtor if they would be willing to pay by instalments or even post dated cheques given the severity of the situation. Be sure to monitor any instalment plan that can be agreed to ensure that the correct amount and date of the payments coming across is being adhered to, call the debtor and find out the situation if any instalment is defaulted on.
  10. The signatory is deceased – Not much you can do immediately with a case like this. There is often a good deal of paperwork to be completed prior to any funds being released from the deceased person’s estate. Verification of the deceased’s position however is essential. A sympathetic and polite approach is required, find out who is dealing with the deceased’s affairs, their contact details, and when they expect payment to be received. Always verify the details given, sometimes accounts can be opened in the deceased’s name by a fraudster to try and obtain goods. 

Privacy Preference Center